Skip to main content
Instructional model · PK-12

Model of Instruction

A model of instruction is the instructional system teachers use to deliver curriculum to students. The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is a research-validated instructional system for delivering high-quality instructional materials (HQIM) through student-led team structures, verified teacher competencies, and district-level instructional systems. The legacy “model of instruction” that most teachers have experienced can be classified as teacher-directed, whether it involves mostly lecture-based instruction with independent taskwork or incorporates teacher-facilitated grouping processes.

Raising rigor, engagement, and achievement in every classroom: the research-based model provides teachers and students with the skills for creating rich and rigorous classroom learning environments where ALL students thrive to higher levels of academic achievement.

Elementary-age students sit around a table together, deep in discussion and using student-driven engagement strategies like team roles and academically rigorous tasks, which are important in raising achievement and closing gaps.
Research

Impact and Results

Studies of the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®, including large-scale studies, found the following outcomes associated with its implementation. For the full body of evidence, see the Research Index and a synthesis of 10 years of research and case studies on the model.

ESSA Tier 2 · Colorado Springs, CO

Higher ELA and math STAR scores with the same curriculum

A study in Colorado Springs School District 11 found that students taught by teachers verified in the model scored an adjusted 22.44 STAR scale-score points higher in ELA and 18.24 points higher in mathematics than matched comparison students in the same grade levels, using the same curriculum, in the same district.

Conducted by Instructional Empowerment’s Applied Research Center in partnership with District 11 using 2025–26 assessment data, the study covered grades 2–11, including 357 students across 18 ELA teacher-grade clusters and 449 students across 20 math teacher-grade clusters. Both differences were statistically significant (ELA p = .045; mathematics p = .011).

Read the full Colorado Springs study (2026) →

Narrowed Achievement Gaps

How Does the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning Support These Outcomes?

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® accomplishes these results for ALL students by equipping teachers and students with a unique, research-based team learning structure that opens access to more rigorous content. Teachers also learn how to develop more rigorous, interdependent learning tasks incorporating existing curricular resources for the student-led learning teams.

Students, in turn, begin to thrive in their team-based structures where each team member becomes a trusted peer and problem solver allowing the team to successfully tackle much more rigorous learning tasks than the teacher may have been comfortable providing when the students were doing individualized or traditional group work.

The research-validated team-based learning structure enables and empowers students to be leaders of their own learning and to turn rigorous tasks from unproductive to productive struggle where the team members help lift each other, quickly developing into a powerful learning community of scholars.

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®:

  • Equips students with the team-based structures for deeper learning through rich and vibrant academic discourse utilizing content vocabulary.
  • Raises authentic engagement with rigorous interdependent tasks that require students to use the team-based structures and curricular resources to problem solve jointly as they develop and practice critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
  • Opens access to the content for ALL team members as the team-based structures require equal voice and participation for each team member while critically thinking their way through rigorous tasks.
  • Develops a sense of belonging and shared academic responsibility among the student teams.
  • Develops students’ agency skills as they learn to self-regulate, peer regulate, and use the provided team-based learning roles, norms, and protocols for respectful debate, resolving team issues, and empathy development.
  • Develops leadership as students develop the skills to lead their own learning and to encourage and support each other while engaged in productive struggle during rigorous tasks.
  • Creates a student-owned learning culture within the team structure, empowering students to bring their unique background knowledge, voice, and culture within a vibrant team-based learning community.

See how teams work in practice on the student-led team learning page, and the deeper learning framework behind the model.

Four students lie on the floor working together on a team task with their books
What educators say

Hear from Educators Using the Model

Curriculum used with rigor
“It’s more than just making sure everyone is using the same resource—it’s also ensuring that resource is getting used in a high-quality, rigorous way with all students and all populations, which I think is just a fundamental difference in how curriculum has functioned in the past.”
Dr. Krystal Rasmussen, Chief of Curriculum, Colorado Springs School District 11
Chief of Curriculum
Dr. Krystal Rasmussen, Colorado Springs School District 11, CO
Higher-level conversations
“I think the biggest difference I see is we’re not stopping at an answer and moving on—we’re asking why. My eight- and nine-year-olds are using verbiage like, ‘Can you please explain the evidence behind your thinking?’—my students are having higher-level conversations. The autonomy my students have is also far superior using the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning. They have become much more independent, better critical thinkers, and it correlates perfectly to their test scores. I had a child in the tenth percentile who was a level 1 become a level 5 and exit Tier 3 reading.”
Emily McCallum, third-grade teacher, Oriole Beach Elementary School
Third-grade teacher
Emily McCallum, Oriole Beach Elementary School, FL
The teacher isn’t doing all of the work
“The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning has absolutely solidified and strengthened our district’s vision of providing classroom environments where the teacher isn’t doing all of the work.”
Dr. Patrick McGee, Superintendent, Woonsocket Education Department
Superintendent
Dr. Patrick McGee, Woonsocket Education Department, RI
Students taking responsibility
“They progress from ‘sage on the stage’ to the students taking responsibility. You can see how it’s changed the whole atmosphere of the school. It gives everyone a sense of pride. It has made us better, more effective teachers and leaders.”
Ronda Hamilton, Principal, Arthur Elementary School
Principal
Ronda Hamilton, Arthur Elementary School, Oklahoma City, OK

Pilot with Implementation Best Practices

We typically recommend that districtwide implementation begins with pilots of volunteer schools and volunteer teachers, building local expertise and momentum for the work as implementing classrooms transform into vibrant, deeper learning environments for all students. Our unique coalition-of-the-willing approach to successful implementation empowers teacher and principal advocacy as they share the transformation in their schools and classrooms with the greater district community.

See school packages and district pilots for the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® →

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning for ALL Students

There has always been deeper learning for some students in schools but not for all students in every classroom, every day. Now it is possible with the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® that provides every teacher and all students with the professional learning, support, and resources for both teachers and their students to achieve deeper, more rigorous learning of the curriculum.

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® provides comprehensive resources, professional learning, expert coaching, and support for:

  • Classroom teachers
  • Professional learning community (PLC) leaders
  • Instructional coaches
  • School leaders
  • District leaders

Educators at every level can align their work and support the implementation of deeper learning for ALL students. See everything included in the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®.

Author and Instructional Empowerment Founder and CEO Michael D. Toth delivers a keynote at the national Building Expertise Educators’ Conference. He explains the neuroscience behind student-led team learning and how it allows ALL students to access deeper learning.

Overcoming Low Rigor, Low Engagement Tier 1 Instruction

Too often Tier 1 instruction is heavily teacher-directed resulting in a lower engagement and more passive learning environment where students are overly dependent upon the teacher. In this environment, teachers often withhold the rigor of the curriculum believing their students will struggle unproductively. This may result in over scaffolding and decreased rigor of learning tasks provided to students.

Teacher-directed, lower rigor, and lower engagement instruction often results in too many students being referred to Tier 2 and Tier 3 interventions creating the upside-down RTI/MTSS pyramid with larger numbers of students in Tier 2 and Tier 3 interventions due to less effective Tier 1 instruction.

Scripting lessons alone has not overcome this issue. Teachers need an instructional process that empowers all students of all ability levels to thrive with more rigorous learning tasks.

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® transitions the classroom learning process and environment from teacher-directed instruction to student-led team learning with rigorous interdependent tasks. The research-validated team-based learning structures empower all students of all ability levels to successfully engage in more rigorous learning tasks, which studies associate with higher learning gains and academic proficiency levels.

Two pyramids - the first represents a well-functioning instructional system. It is an upright pyramid with Tier 3 at the top as the smallest part, Tier 2 in the middle, and Tier 3 as the biggest part of the pyramid at the foundation. The second pyramid represents a poorly functioning system. It is an upside down pyramid where Tier 3 is now the largest part, then Tier 2, and Tier 1 is the smallest part.

Low rigor instruction results in the upside-down RTI/MTSS pyramid.

Video: How to Achieve Rigor in the Classroom.

Redesigned Tier 1 Instruction That Lifts ALL Students

The legacy “model of instruction” that most teachers have experienced can be classified as teacher-directed, whether it involves mostly lecture-based instruction with independent taskwork or incorporates teacher-facilitated grouping processes. Both of these are teacher-directed learning processes that require students to be dependent upon the teacher.

Redesigned Tier 1 Instruction through the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® transforms the instructional process to student-led team learning that fully engages students in interdependent rigorous tasks using your adopted curricular resources.

By infusing a research-based teaming structure, all students are then empowered to successfully engage in rich content discourse utilizing the curricular resources. The Model is designed for more rigorous learning by providing roles, responsibilities, norms of conduct, and resources for students to turn unproductive struggle to productive struggle when completing more rigorous tasks.

Learn how student-led team learning works or explore the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® product.

A diagram shows a teacher-directed classroom, represented by dots for students either sitting in rows or groups with arrows pointing to the teacher because the teacher is doing all the support and communication. This is contrasted with a diagram showing a student-led deeper learning classroom, represented by dots of students in teams, with communication and support flowing from student to student and between the teams and teacher.
Listen to a district’s experience of adopting the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning. Video Credit: School District U-46, IL.

Opens Access to the Rigor of the Curriculum for ALL Students

Rigorous materials only translate to rigorous learning when the classroom has structures that make them accessible for every student. The same materials can produce rigorous, student-led learning in one classroom and lower-rigor, surface-level work in another. Read more in The Missing Piece in HQIM Implementation.

The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® opens access to the rigor of the curriculum for all students through the following:

Eight ways the model opens access to the curriculum
  1. The professional learning and resources equip teachers to plan interdependent learning tasks at the intent and rigor of the standards that incorporate curricular resources. This puts curricular resources directly into the hands of students.
  2. The team-based learning structure enables all students to fully participate in the learning task with equal voice during content discourse utilizing content vocabulary.
  3. The unique protocols allow for students of different ability levels within the learning team to socialize their background knowledge helping to lift students that may have been academically or socially behind or were shy to participate prior to teaming.
  4. The roles, norms, and protocols empower students to have deeper and richer discourse around the content during the interdependent tasks as they develop independent critical thinking, problem-solving, and leadership skills.
  5. Students develop higher agency skills as the protocols and norms help them better self-regulate and peer regulate to stay on track during more rigorous learning tasks.
  6. Students are able to engage in and sustain productive struggle during more rigorous learning tasks as the norms and protocols create a learning culture of peer encouragement and support to help all students turn unproductive into productive struggle.
  7. Students are empowered with more voice and choice while critically thinking their way through the learning task, creating authentic engagement. As students are leading their own learning during teaming with more rigorous interdependent tasks, teachers are able to transition to a coach of the learning with freed time to visually and auditorily monitor for deeper learning and ensure all students are fully benefiting.
  8. Students continue to develop academically and with greater agency as they successfully take on more challenging learning tasks. This creates a virtuous cycle of a continuously improving learning environment that develops all students’ efficacy.

Articles and resources for using a model of instruction to activate the rigor in your curriculum

The Missing Piece in HQIM Implementation: How to Get Higher Achievement from Your Existing Curriculum
Activating the Rigor in Your Curriculum Implementation: A Series for District Leaders
Why Students with Disabilities Are Still Left Out—And How to Change That with Deeper Learning
English Learners Are Capable of More—If We Make the Shift to Deeper Learning

Explore Services

School packages for the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®

Toolkits, professional development, and coaching for teachers and school leaders.

District pilots for the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®

A partnership that builds district capacity to lead and sustain the work.

School Turnaround

Partnership support for schools identified for comprehensive or targeted improvement.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®

What is a model of instruction?
A model of instruction is the instructional system teachers use to deliver curriculum to students. The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is a research-validated instructional system for delivering high-quality instructional materials (HQIM) through student-led team structures, verified teacher competencies, and district-level instructional systems. The legacy “model of instruction” that most teachers have experienced can be classified as teacher-directed, whether it involves mostly lecture-based instruction with independent taskwork or incorporates teacher-facilitated grouping processes.
What is the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning®?
The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is a research-validated instructional system that helps teachers put adopted curriculum into practice so that all students are engaged in rigorous thinking, every day, in every classroom. It equips teachers and students with a unique, research-based team learning structure that opens access to more rigorous content.
How is the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® different from teacher-directed instruction?
The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® transitions the classroom learning process and environment from teacher-directed instruction to student-led team learning with rigorous interdependent tasks. Students use roles, responsibilities, norms of conduct, and resources to turn unproductive struggle to productive struggle when completing more rigorous tasks.
Who is the Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® for?
The Model of Instruction for Deeper Learning® is for all students, including English learners and students with disabilities, in all grade levels and all subject areas. It provides support for educators in every role: classroom teachers, professional learning community (PLC) leaders, instructional coaches, school leaders, and district leaders. Educators at every level can align their work and support the implementation of deeper learning for ALL students.
How do schools and districts get started?
We typically recommend that districtwide implementation begins with pilots of volunteer schools and volunteer teachers, building local expertise and momentum for the work as implementing classrooms transform into vibrant, deeper learning environments for all students.
What does the research say about the model?
In Colorado Springs School District 11, students taught by teachers verified in the model scored an adjusted 22.44 STAR scale-score points higher in ELA and 18.24 points higher in mathematics than matched comparison students in the same grade levels, using the same curriculum, in the same district. The District 11 study meets ESSA Tier 2 (moderate evidence). For the full body of evidence, see the Research Index and a synthesis of 10 years of research and case studies on the model.

Schedule a Free Consultation to Learn More About Our Model of Instruction

Tell us about your school or district. One of our experts, all former educators and school leaders, will reach out.

  • Talk with expert career educators, not salespeople
  • Hear how the model works and best practices for implementation
  • No obligation